root ff9823b871 scrum audit re-run: 35 → 43 / 60 after Phase A-E + S0.3
Re-runs the SCRUM.md framework against HEAD (4840c10) to score the
delta from the audit baseline at 91edd43. Composite +8.

Scoring deltas:
  Reproducibility       7 → 9  (just verify, just doctor, pre-push hook)
  Test Coverage         6 → 8  (168 proof harness assertions; Go-test
                                gaps in shared/storeclient remain)
  Trust Boundary        7 → 7  (no code change; R-001/R-007 open)
  Memory Correctness    3 → 4  (vectord persistence proven; Mem0
                                pathway/playbook still not ported)
  Deployment Readiness  4 → 5  (just doctor; REPLICATION/systemd open)
  Maintainability       8 → 8  (spine unchanged; harness obeys
                                CLAUDE_REFACTOR_GUARDRAILS)

Risk register changes:
  R-004 (smokes not gated)        CLOSED — just verify + pre-push hook
  R-005 (cmd/main.go untested)    partial — proof harness covers wiring
  R-012 (empty tests/ dir)        CLOSED — populated by harness
  R-001/R-002/R-003/R-006/R-007/R-008/R-009/R-010 unchanged

Sprint 0 progress:
  S0.1 just doctor               DONE
  S0.3 just verify + pre-push    DONE
  S0.6 tests/ dir cleanup        DONE
  S0.2 just smoke-fixtures       open
  S0.4 cmd/main_test × 6         partial (harness coverage; go-test gap)
  S0.5 shared/storeclient tests  open  (HIGH risks still unaddressed)

New finding from this rerun (worth recording):
  Queryd refresh-tick race in 04_query_correctness — cache-warm
  binaries fire SELECTs faster than queryd's 500ms refresh tick.
  Caught by integration mode going 104/0/1 → 102/1/1, fixed at
  4840c10 with proof_wait_for_sql helper. Exactly the failure-mode
  the harness was designed to catch.

Original 5 audit reports preserved as immutable history at
91edd43; this file documents the delta only.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-04-29 05:37:45 -05:00
..