lakehouse/STATE_OF_PLAY.md
root 0af62861d2
Some checks failed
lakehouse/auditor 9 blocking issues: cloud: claim not backed — "Verified end-to-end via playwright on devop.live/lakehouse:"
STATE_OF_PLAY: refresh for 2026-05-02 wave (Lance gauntlet + parity + housekeeping)
Anchor was 5 days stale. Adds the 12-commit wave (Lance backend hardening,
sidecar drop, observability parity, gitignore cleanup, gray-zone content
add) with verification status for each. Updates DO NOT RELITIGATE with
the 4 new things this wave makes load-bearing:
- python sidecar dropped from hot path (don't wire it back)
- lance gauntlet shipped (don't re-discover the bugs we just fixed)
- 32/32 cross-runtime parity (don't build a 6th probe for already-covered surface)
- ARCHITECTURE_COMPARISON.md is the single source of truth for cross-runtime decisions

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-05-02 22:23:36 -05:00

270 lines
21 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters

This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.

# STATE OF PLAY — Lakehouse
**Last verified:** 2026-05-02 evening CDT
**Verified by:** live probe (smoke 9/9, parity 32/32, gateway restarted), not memory.
> **Read this FIRST.** When the user says "we're working on lakehouse," they mean the working code captured below — NOT what `git log` framed as "the cutover" or what memory snapshots from 2 days ago suggest. If memory contradicts this file, this file wins. Update it when something is verified working — not when a phase finishes.
---
## WHAT LANDED 2026-05-01 → 2026-05-02 (10 commits this wave)
| Commit | What | Verified |
|---|---|---|
| `5d30b3d` | lance: auto-build doc_id btree in `lance_migrate` handler | doc-fetch ~5ms (was ~100ms full scan) on scale_test_10m |
| `044650a` | lance-bench: same scalar build post-IVF (matches gateway) | cargo check clean |
| `7594725` | lance: 4-pack — `sanitize_lance_err` + 7 unit tests + 9-probe smoke + 10M re-bench | smoke 9/9 PASS, tests 7/7 PASS |
| `98b6647` | gateway: `IterateResponse.trace_id` echoed; session_log_path enabled | parity probes see one unified JSONL |
| `57bde63` | gateway: trace-id propagation + coordinator session JSONL (Rust parity with Go wave) | session_log_parity 4/4 |
| `ba928b1` | aibridge: drop Python sidecar from hot path; AiClient → direct Ollama | aibridge tests 32/32 PASS, /ai/embed live 768d |
| `654797a` | gateway: pub `extract_json` + `parity_extract_json` bin | extract_json_parity 12/12 |
| `c5654d4` | docs: pointer to `golangLAKEHOUSE/docs/ARCHITECTURE_COMPARISON.md` | — |
| `150cc3b` | aibridge: LRU embed cache, 236× RPS warm (78ms → 129us p50) | load test |
| `9eed982` | mcp-server: /_go/* pass-through for G5 cutover slice | — |
| `6e34ef7` | gitignore: stop tracking 100+ runtime ephemera (data/_*, lance, logs, node_modules) | untracked dropped 100+ → 0 |
| `41b0a99` | chore: add 33 real items that were sitting untracked (scripts, scenarios, kimi reports, dev UIs) | clean working tree |
**Cross-runtime parity (post-this-wave):** 32/32 across 5 probes — `validator(6/6) + extract_json(12/12) + session_log(4/4) + materializer(2/2) + embed(8/8)`. Run `cd /home/profit/golangLAKEHOUSE && for p in scripts/cutover/parity/*.sh; do bash "$p"; done` to re-verify.
**Lance backend (was untested 5 days ago, now gauntlet-ready):**
- `cargo test -p vectord-lance --release` → 7/7 PASS
- `./scripts/lance_smoke.sh` → 9/9 PASS against live gateway
- `reports/lance_10m_rebench_2026-05-02.md` — search warm ~20ms / cold ~46ms median, doc-fetch ~5ms post-btree
---
## VERIFIED WORKING RIGHT NOW
### The client demo (Staffing Co-Pilot)
**Public URL:** `https://devop.live/lakehouse/` — 200, "Staffing Co-Pilot" (159 KB SPA, leaflet maps, dark theme).
**Local URL:** `http://localhost:3700/` — same page, served by `mcp-server/index.ts` (PID 1271, started 09:48 CDT today).
**The staffers console** (the one the client was thoroughly impressed with):
- `https://devop.live/lakehouse/console` — 200, "Lakehouse — What Your Staffing System Would Do" (26 KB)
- Pulls project index via `/api/catalog/datasets` (36 datasets) + playbook memory via `/api/vectors/playbook_memory/stats` (4,701 entries with embeddings, real ops like *"fill: Maintenance Tech x2 in Milwaukee, WI"*)
Client-visible flow that works end-to-end on the public URL:
| Endpoint | Sample output |
|---|---|
| `GET /api/catalog/datasets` | 36 datasets indexed: timesheets 1M, call_log 800K, workers_500k 500K, email_log 500K, workers_100k 100K, candidates 100K, placements 50K, job_orders 15K, successful_playbooks_live 2,077 |
| `GET /api/vectors/playbook_memory/stats` | 4,701 fill operations with embeddings |
| `GET /system/summary` | 36 datasets, 2.98M rows, 60 indexes, 500K workers loaded, 1K candidates |
| `POST /intelligence/staffing_forecast` | 744 Production Workers needed in 30d, 11,281 bench (4,687 reliable), coverage 1,444%, risk=ok. Same for Electrician (need 32, bench 2,440) and Maintenance Tech (need 17, bench 5,004). |
| `POST /intelligence/permit_contracts` | permit `3442956` $500K → 3 Production Workers, 886-candidate pool, 95% fill, $36K gross. 5 more Chicago permits with 8 workers each, same pool, 95% fill, $96K each. |
| `POST /intelligence/market` | major Chicago permits ranked: $730M O'Hare, $615M 307 N Michigan, $580M casino, $445M Loop transit (real geo coords). |
| `POST /intelligence/permit_entities` | architects + contractors from permit contacts (e.g. "KACPRZYNSKI, ANDY", "SLS ELECTRICAL SERVICE"). |
| `POST /intelligence/activity` + `/intelligence/arch_signals` + `/intelligence/chat` | all 200 |
The demo tells the story: *"upcoming Chicago contracts → workers needed → coverage from the bench → architects/contractors involved → revenue and margin."* That's the "live data + anticipating contracts + complete workflow" pitch — working as of right now.
### Backend, verified live this session
| Surface | State |
|---|---|
| Gateway `:3100` | up, 4 providers configured, `/v1/health` 200 with 500K workers loaded |
| MCP server `:3700` (Co-Pilot demo) | up, all `/intelligence/*` endpoints respond |
| VCP UI `:3950` | started this session, `/data/*` 200, real numbers |
| Observer `:3800` | ring full (2,000/2,000) — older events evicted, query Langfuse for 24h-ago state |
| Sidecar `:3200` | up |
| Langfuse `:3001` | recording, `gw:/log` + `v1.chat:openrouter` traces visible |
| LLM Team UI `:5000` | up, only `extract` mode registered |
| OpenCode fleet | **40 models reachable through one `sk-*` key** (verified live `GET https://opencode.ai/zen/v1/models`) |
OpenCode catalog (live):
- Claude: opus-4-7, opus-4-6, opus-4-5, opus-4-1, sonnet-4-6, sonnet-4-5, sonnet-4, haiku-4-5
- GPT-5: 5.5-pro, 5.5, 5.4-pro, 5.4, 5.4-mini, 5.4-nano, 5.3-codex-spark, 5.3-codex, 5.2, 5.2-codex, 5.1-codex-max, 5.1-codex, 5.1-codex-mini, 5.1, 5-codex, 5-nano, 5
- Gemini: 3.1-pro, 3-flash
- GLM: 5.1, 5
- Minimax: m2.7, m2.5
- Kimi: k2.6, k2.5
- Qwen: 3.6-plus, 3.5-plus
- Other: BIG-PKL (was a typo-prone name in the catalog, model id starts with "big-pkl-something")
- Free tier: minimax-m2.5-free, hy3-preview-free, ling-2.6-flash-free, trinity-large-preview-free
### The substrate (frozen — do not re-architect)
- Distillation v1.0.0 at tag `e7636f2`**145/145 bun tests pass, 22/22 acceptance, 16/16 audit-full**
- Output: `data/_kb/distilled_{facts,procedures,config_hints}.jsonl` + `data/vectors/distilled_{factual,procedural,config_hint}_v20260423102847.parquet`
- Auditor cross-lineage: Kimi K2.6 ↔ Haiku 4.5 alternation, Opus auto-promote on diffs >100k chars, **per-PR cap=3 with auto-reset on new head SHA**
- Pathway memory: 88 traces, 11/11 successful replays (probation gate crossed)
- Mode runner: 5 native modes; `codereview_isolation` is default; composed-corpus auto-downgrade verified Apr 26 (composed lost 5/5 vs isolation, p=0.031)
### Matrix indexer
30+ live corpora including:
- 5 versions of `workers_500k_v1..v9` (50K embedded chunks each)
- 11 batched 2K-row shards `w500k_b3..b17`
- `chicago_permits_v1` (3,420), `resumes_100k_v2` (100K candidates), `ethereal_workers_v1` (10K)
- `lakehouse_arch_v1` (2,119), `lakehouse_symbols_v1` (2,470), `lakehouse_answers_v1` (1,269), `scrum_findings_v1` (1,260)
- `kb_team_runs_v1` (12,693) + `kb_team_runs_agent` (4,407) — LLM-team play history embedded
- `distilled_factual_v20260423102507` (8) — distillation output
### Code health
- `cargo check --workspace`**0 warnings, 0 errors**
- `bun test auditor + tests/distillation`**145/145 pass**
- `ui/server.ts` + `auditor.ts` bundle clean
---
## DO NOT RELITIGATE
- **PR #11 is merged into `origin/main` as `ed57eda`** — do not "still need to merge PR #11."
- **Distillation tag `distillation-v1.0.0` at `e7636f2` is FROZEN** — do not re-architect schemas, scorer rules, audit fixtures.
- **Kimi forensic HOLD verdict (2026-04-27) was 2/8 false + 6/8 latent** — do not re-debate, see `reports/kimi/audit-last-week-full.md`.
- **`candidates_safe` `vertical` column bug** — fixed at catalog metadata layer in commit `c3c9c21`. Do not "discover" it again.
- **Decisions A/B/C/D from `synthetic-data-gap-report.md`** — all four scripts shipped today (`d56f08e`, `940737d`, `c3c9c21`). Do not "ask J for approval."
- **`workers_500k.phone` type fixup** — already string. The fixup script is idempotent; running it is a no-op.
- **`client_workerskjkk` typo dataset** — was breaking every SQL query (catalog had it registered, file didn't exist). Removed via `DELETE /catalog/datasets/by-name/client_workerskjkk` this session. Do not re-add. Adding a startup gate that errors on unrecognized parquet names is the long-term fix per now.md Step 2C.
- **Python sidecar dropped from hot path 2026-05-02 (`ba928b1`)** — AiClient calls Ollama directly. Do not "wire python embedding back in." `lab_ui.py` + `pipeline_lab.py` keep running as dev-only UIs (not on the runtime path).
- **Lance backend gauntlet (2026-05-02)** — sanitizer over all 5 routes, 7 unit tests, 9-probe smoke, 10M re-bench. The `doc_id` btree auto-builds inside `lance_migrate` AND `lance-bench`. Do not "discover" the missing scalar index again or the leaked filesystem paths in error bodies.
- **Cross-runtime parity = 32/32** across 5 probes in `golangLAKEHOUSE/scripts/cutover/parity/`. Do not "build a parity probe for X" without checking — validator, extract_json, session_log, materializer, and embed are all already covered.
- **Decisions tracker is `golangLAKEHOUSE/docs/ARCHITECTURE_COMPARISON.md`** — single living source of truth for cross-runtime decisions. As of 2026-05-02 it has 0 `_open_` code work items; only 2 strategic items left (Lance vs Parquet+HNSW-with-spilling, Go-vs-Rust primary cutover).
---
## FIXES MADE THIS SESSION (2026-04-27 evening)
1. **`crates/gateway/src/v1/iterate.rs:93`** — `state``_state` (cleared the one cargo warning).
2. **`lakehouse-ui.service` (Dioxus)** — disabled. Was failing 7,242 times against a missing `target/dx/ui/debug/web/public` build dir. `systemctl stop && disable`.
3. **VCP UI on `:3950`** — started `bun run ui/server.ts` (PID 1162212, log `/tmp/lakehouse_ui.log`). `/data/*` endpoints now 200 with real data.
4. **`client_workerskjkk` catalog entry** — `DELETE /catalog/datasets/by-name/client_workerskjkk` removed the dead manifest. **This was the actual root cause** of `/system/summary` reporting `workers_500k_rows: 0` and the demo showing zero bench. Every SQL query was failing schema inference on the missing file before reaching its target table. Fixed → `workers_500k_rows: 500000`, `candidates_rows: 1000`, demo coverage flipped from "critical 0%" to actual percentages on devop.live/lakehouse.
## FIXES MADE THIS SESSION (2026-04-28 early — face pool)
5. **Synthetic StyleGAN face pool — 1000 faces, gender+race+age tagged.** `scripts/staffing/fetch_face_pool.py` fetches from thispersondoesnotexist.com; `scripts/staffing/tag_face_pool.py --min-age 22` runs deepface and excludes minors. `data/headshots/manifest.jsonl` now has gender (494 men / 458 women), race (caucasian 662 · east_asian 128 · hispanic 86 · middle_eastern 59 · black 14 · south_asian 3), age, and 48 minor exclusions. Server pool = 952 servable faces.
6. **`mcp-server/index.ts:1308` `/headshots/:key` route** — gender×race×age intersection bucketing with graceful fallback (gender-only → all). Same key always returns same face; different keys spread evenly.
7. **`/headshots/_thumbs/` pre-resized 384×384 webp** (60× smaller: 587KB → ~11KB). Without this, 40-card grids overran Chrome's parallel-connection budget and ~75% of tiles never finished decoding. Generated via parallel ffmpeg (`xargs -P 8`); `.gitignore`d.
8. **`mcp-server/search.html` + `console.html`** — dropped `img.loading='lazy'`. With 11KB thumbs, eager load is cheap (~500KB for 50 cards) and avoids the off-screen race that lazy decode produced.
9. **ComfyUI on-demand uniqueness — `serve_imagegen.py:32`** added `seed` to `_cache_key()` (was caching by prompt only — 3 different worker seeds collapsed to 1 cached image). Verified: seed=839185194/195/196 → 3 distinct md5s.
10. **`mcp-server/index.ts:1234` `/headshots/generate/:key`** — ComfyUI hot-path that derives a deterministic-per-worker seed via djb2-style hash; cold ~1.5s, cached ~1ms. Worker prompt format: `professional corporate headshot portrait of a {age}-year-old {race} {gender}, {role}, neutral expression, plain studio background, soft natural lighting, sharp focus, photorealistic, dslr`. Cache at `data/headshots_gen/` (gitignored, regeneratable).
11. **Confidence-default name resolution** in `search.html``genderFor()` and `guessEthnicityFromFirstName()` lookup tables (FEMALE_NAMES, MALE_NAMES, NAMES_HISPANIC, NAMES_BLACK, NAMES_SOUTH_ASIAN, NAMES_EAST_ASIAN, NAMES_MIDDLE_EASTERN). Xavier → man+hispanic, Aisha → woman+black, etc. Every worker resolves to a face-pool bucket.
End-to-end verified: playwright run on `https://devop.live/lakehouse/?q=forklift+operators+IL` → 21/21 cards loaded, 0 broken, all 384×384 webp thumbs.
---
## OPEN — but not blocking the demo
| Item | What | When to act |
|---|---|---|
| `modes.toml` `staffing_inference.matrix_corpus` | still says `workers_500k_v8`. v9 in vector index is from Apr 17 (raw-sourced, not safe-view). The new `build_workers_v9.sh` rebuilds from `workers_safe`. | Run when you have 30+ min for the rebuild. |
| Open PRs #6, #7, #10 | sitting since Apr 22-24, auditor verdicts on disk at `data/_auditor/kimi_verdicts/{6,7,10}-*.json` | Read verdicts, decide reconcile/close. |
| `test/enrich-prd-pipeline` branch | 35 unmerged commits, includes more-evolved auditor/inference.ts (666 vs main's 580 lines), curation+fact-extractor wiring | Reconcile or formally archive — see `memory/project_unmerged_architecture_work.md`. |
| `federation-hnsw-trials` stash | Lance + S3/MinIO prototype, `aws-config` crate added, 708 insertions | Phase B from EXECUTION_PLAN.md — revisit when Parquet vector ceiling actually hurts. |
| `candidates` manifest drift | manifest 100K vs SQL 1K. Cosmetic. | Run a metadata resync if it matters. |
---
## RUNTIME CHEATSHEET
```bash
# Verify the demo (public + local both work)
curl -sS https://devop.live/lakehouse/ # Co-Pilot HTML
curl -sS https://devop.live/lakehouse/console # staffers console
curl -sS -X POST https://devop.live/lakehouse/intelligence/staffing_forecast \
-d '{}' -H 'content-type: application/json' \
| jq '.forecast[] | {role, demand_workers, bench_total, coverage_pct, risk}'
# Restart sequence (after Rust changes)
sudo systemctl restart lakehouse.service # gateway :3100
sudo systemctl restart lakehouse-auditor # auditor daemon
sudo systemctl restart lakehouse-observer # observer :3800
# UI bun on :3950 is NOT systemd-managed (lakehouse-ui.service is disabled).
# Restart manually: kill <pid>; nohup bun run ui/server.ts > /tmp/lakehouse_ui.log 2>&1 &
# Health checks
curl -sS http://localhost:3100/v1/health | jq # workers_count, providers
curl -sS http://localhost:3100/vectors/pathway/stats | jq
curl -sS http://localhost:3100/v1/usage | jq # since-restart cost
curl -sS http://localhost:3700/system/summary | jq # dataset counts
```
---
## VISION — what we're actually building (not what's done)
J's framing for the legacy staffing company:
- Pull live data, anticipate contracts based on Chicago permits → real architect/contractor associations, headcount, time period, money, scope.
- Hybrid + memory index → search large corpora cheaply.
- Email comes in → verify against contract; SMS comes in → alert when index changes.
- Real-time.
- Invent metrics nobody else has using the hybrid index.
- Next stage: workers download an app → geolocation clock-in → automatic responsiveness measurement, no user effort, with incentives for using it.
- Find people getting certificates (passive cert tracking).
- Pull union data → bring contracts that work for **employees**, not just employers.
- All metrics visible, nothing hidden, value-aligned with what each side actually needs.
If a future session is shaving away from this vision toward "fix the cutover" or "land Phase X," the vision wins. Phases are scaffolding for the vision, not the goal.
---
## CURRENT PLAN — fix the demo for the legacy staffing client
Built from playwright audit of the live demo (2026-04-27 evening). Each item ends in something the client can SEE, not internal cleanups.
**Demo state is anchored by git tag `demo-2026-04-27`** (commit `ed57eda`, the merge of PR #11). To restore code state: `git checkout demo-2026-04-27`. To restore runtime state: `DELETE /catalog/datasets/by-name/client_workerskjkk` (catalog hot-fix is not in git).
### P1 — Search box that actually filters (highest visible impact)
**Problem:** typing in `#sq` and pressing Enter fires `POST /intelligence/chat` with body `{"message":"<query>"}`. The state (`#sst`) and role (`#srl`) selects are ignored — never sent in the body. So every search returns a generic chat completion, never a SQL+vector hybrid filter against `workers_500k`. That is the "cached/generic response" the client sees.
**Fix:** in `mcp-server/search.html`, change the search-submit handler to call the real worker search endpoint with `{query, state, role, top_k}`. The MCP `search_workers` tool surface already exists; route the form there. Render returned worker rows in the existing card grid.
**Done when:** typing "forklift" + state IL + role "Forklift Operator" returns ≤ top_k IL Forklift Operators, and changing state to WI returns different workers.
### P2 — Contractor-name click → `/contractor` profile page
**Problem:** clicking a contractor name in any rendered card stays on `/lakehouse/`. URL doesn't change.
**Fix:** wrap contractor names in `<a href="/contractor?name=<encoded>">`. The page `mcp-server/contractor.html` (14.8 KB, "Contractor Profile · Staffing Co-Pilot") already exists at `/contractor` and the data endpoint `/intelligence/contractor_profile` already returns rich data.
**Then check contractor.html actually shows:** full history of every record the database has on that contractor + heat map of locations underneath + relevant info (per J 2026-04-27). If the page is incomplete, finish it. Otherwise just wire the link.
**Done when:** clicking "KACPRZYNSKI, ANDY" opens a profile with: every Chicago permit they're contact_1 or contact_2 on, a leaflet map with markers for each address, and any matched workers from prior placements at their sites.
### P3 — Substrate signal at the bottom shows the right numbers
**Problem:** J reports the bottom panel says "playbook memory empty, 80 traces 0 replies." Reality from the live endpoints: `/api/vectors/playbook_memory/stats` = 4,701 entries with embeddings; `/vectors/pathway/stats` = 88 traces, 11/11 replays.
**Fix:** find the renderer in search.html that builds the substrate signal panel; verify it's hitting the right endpoints and reading the right keys; fix shape mismatches.
**Done when:** bottom panel shows real numbers (4,701 playbooks, 88 traces, 11/11 replays) and references at least one specific recent operation from the playbook stats sample.
### P4 — Top nav reflects today's architecture
**Problem:** Walkthrough/Architecture/Spec/Onboard/Alerts/Workspaces tabs all return 200 but content is from old architecture. Doesn't mention: gateway scratchpad, memory indexer, ranker, mode runner, OpenCode 40-model fleet, distillation substrate, auditor cross-lineage.
**Fix:** rewrite `mcp-server/proof.html` (or add a single new page "What's running" that replaces Architecture+Spec) to describe what's actually shipped as of `demo-2026-04-27`. Keep one architecture page, drop redundancy. Either complete or hide Onboard/Alerts/Workspaces — J's call which.
**Done when:** the architecture page tells a non-technical reader, in 2 minutes, what each piece does in coordinator-relatable terms ("intern that read every email", not "3-stage adversarial inference pipeline").
### P5 — Caching for the project-index build_signal (J flagged unfinished)
**Problem:** "we never finished our caching for project index build signal it's not pulling new information." Need to find what `build_signal` refers to. Likely a scrum/auditor signal that should rebuild the `lakehouse_arch_v1` corpus on commit but isn't wired to.
**Fix:** identify the build-signal pipeline (likely in `auditor/` or `crates/vectord/`), wire its emit to a corpus rebuild, verify by making a test commit and watching the new chunk appear in `/vectors/indexes` for `lakehouse_arch_v1`.
**Done when:** committing a new file to `crates/` causes `lakehouse_arch_v1` chunk_count to increase within N minutes.
### P0 — Anchor the demo state (DONE)
Tagged `ed57eda` as `demo-2026-04-27`. Future sessions: `git checkout demo-2026-04-27` to land in this exact code state.
---
## EXECUTION ORDER
1. **P1 first** — biggest visible bug, ~30-60 min
2. **P2 next** — contractor click is the second-biggest "doesn't work" the client sees, ~20 min if profile is mostly done
3. **P3** — small fix, big "looks alive" win
4. **P4** — biggest scope; might split across sessions
5. **P5** — feature work, only after the visible bugs are fixed
Each item commits independently with the format `demo: P<n> — <one-line>` so the commit log doubles as a progress journal. After each merge to main, re-tag `demo-latest` to point at the new HEAD.
Stop here and let J pick which item to start with. Do not silently extend scope.